This post may contain affiliate links — meaning we get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through our links, at no cost to you. We carefully curate our affiliate partnerships and only work with companies we like and believe in. Earning commissions like this helps us sustain our blog but the opinions we share are always our own.
Recipe for Romance: From 1957 Campus Secrets to Small-Town Love
Romance can be fizzy fun. It can also carry the weight of culture, history and personal reckoning. This week’s pairing proves both can exist in the same breath.
In Season 3 Episode 6 of Romance on the Rocks, we paired Odd Girl Out by Ann Bannon with Savor It by Tarah DeWitt. On the surface, they could not be more different. One is a 1957 campus novel that helped shape lesbian fiction. The other is a 2024 small-town romance set in Spunes, OR. Yet both wrestle with longing, agency and the question of who we become when love forces a decision.
Odd Girl Out by Ann Bannon
Published in 1957, Odd Girl Out sits at the beginning of lesbian pulp fiction but reads with more tenderness than scandal.
Laura arrives at college already carrying anxiety from her parents’ divorce. She’s shy, rigid and desperate to belong. Enter Beth, confident and magnetic, the kind of woman who seems to move through campus without fear. Laura’s fascination slowly shifts into something deeper and what follows is a secret relationship shaped by the reality of its time.
The jealousy feels young because it is. The possessiveness is uncomfortable because first love often is. Bannon does not soften those edges. She lets the characters be immature, reactive and flawed.
What elevates the novel is its refusal to create villains. Even when a love triangle emerges, it does so without caricature. Beth’s connection with Charlie is real. Laura’s heartbreak is real. No one is reduced to a plot device.
The 1950s setting adds pressure. Secrecy is survival. Victim-blaming is normalized. Self-harm appears not as spectacle but as quiet consequence. The ending resists a tidy morality lesson and instead chooses emotional truth. Love, the book suggests, can matter deeply even if it does not last forever.
Spice Level: 🌶️ Green Pepper (1/5)
Closed door. Emotionally rich. Historically significant.
Read Odd Girl Out
Savor It by Tarah DeWitt
Where Odd Girl Out operates under restriction, Savor It thrives in emotional freedom.
Fisher Lang is a burned-out New York chef whose temper cost him a Michelin star and his job. Still grieving his sister’s death, he lands in Spunes, OR to help open a new restaurant and rebuild his reputation. He also has a teenage niece to care for, whether he feels ready or not.
Sage Byrd is a high school teacher with a hobby farm and deep community ties. Their meet-cute leads to a fake dating setup that quickly becomes something more grounded. What stands out is not miscommunication. It’s communication.
They talk. They process. They show up.
The Festival of Spunes provides local stakes but the emotional engine is grief and repair. Fisher learns presence. Sage defends joy without apology. Indy, navigating her own loss, becomes the quiet center of the story.
The heat builds at a measured pace and lands firmly at jalapeño. Open door but earned. Chemistry supported by vulnerability.
Spice Level: 🌶️🌶️🌶️ Jalapeño (3/5)
Open door. Banter-driven. Emotionally layered.
Read or Listen to Savor It
- 🎧 Libro.fm (Support your local bookstore)
- 🎧 Audible
- 📖 Amazon
- 📱 Kindle
- 📚 The Ripped Bodice
Why These Books Work Together
One story asks what love costs when the world says it’s wrong. The other asks what love requires when the world gives you room to choose.
In 1957, love risks safety. In modern Spunes, love risks pride and vulnerability.
Both novels argue romance is not just about who you end up with. It’s about who you grow into along the way.
We dive deeper into both books, including audiobook narration, spice levels and our infamous booby prize, in Season 3 Episode 6 of Romance on the Rocks.
Want More?
Have you read either of these novels? What did you think of them? Comment below! We’d love to hear from you. Want to listen to the podcast episode? We’re available on pretty much all your favorite podcast streaming services. Or you can visit our podcast player page here.
Are you a hopeless romantic and bookish biddy like us? We’d love to have you join in our adventures by signing up for our email list. Just fill out the form below!
